---
title: "Peebles v. JRK Property Case Summary: Recent Massachusetts Case Defining Proper Security Deposit Handling"
description: Recent massachusetts case explains proper security deposit handling, providing factors to determine what is damage (that can be deducted from the security deposit) versus what is reasonable wear and tear (that cannot be deducted from the security deposit).
image: https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/hubfs/AI-Generated%20Media/Images/The%20image%20depicts%20a%20courtroom%20setting%20with%20a%20judge%20presiding%20over%20a%20case%20The%20judge%20an%20older%20man%20in%20a%20black%20robe%20sits%20behind%20a%20wooden%20bench%20looking%20att-1.png
---

[Skip to main content](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog/peebles-v.-jrk-property-case-summary-recent-massachusetts-case-defining-proper-security-deposit-handling#main)

[![Clifford Law Boston](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Clifford-Law-Boston-Blue.png?width=250&height=66&name=Clifford-Law-Boston-Blue.png) ![Clifford Law Boston](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Clifford-Law-Boston-Blue.png?width=250&height=66&name=Clifford-Law-Boston-Blue.png)](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com)

- Show submenu for Practice Areas Practice Areas 
  
    - [Tenant](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/tenant-legal-services)
    - [Landlord](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/landlord-legal-services)
    - [Consumer Protection](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/consumer-protection)
    - [Other Real Estate](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/other-real-estate)
- [About](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/about)
- [Blog](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog)

Open main navigation

Close main navigation

- Show submenu for Practice Areas Practice Areas 
  
    - Practice Areas
    - [Tenant](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/tenant-legal-services)
    - [Landlord](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/landlord-legal-services)
    - [Consumer Protection](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/consumer-protection)
    - [Other Real Estate](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/other-real-estate)
- [About](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/about)
- [Blog](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog)
- [Contact Us](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/contact)

[Contact Us](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/contact)

# Peebles v. JRK Property Case Summary: Recent Massachusetts Case Defining Proper Security Deposit Handling

 by [Ami Clifford](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog/author/ami-clifford)

October 25, 2025

Giving a security deposit has long felt like a gamble for Massachusetts renters. Two former tenants sued for what they considered to be improper deductions made by their prior landlord from their security deposit.  Recently, the highest court in Massachusetts, the Supreme Judicial Court made it clear that many deductions that are routinely made by landlords are improper.

*Peebles v*. *JRK Property Holdings, Inc., & others* (SJC-13702).

 

The case garnered attention from both the landlord and tenant perspectives, with amicus briefs from the Greater Boston Real Estate Board representing real estate professional perspectives the Community Action Agency of Somerville representing tenant perspectives, and the Attorney General representing their position.  Here are some key points to take away from this case.

 

**IS IT DAMAGE OR REASONABLE WEAR AND TEAR?**

The Massachusetts security deposit statute, G. L. c. 186, § 15B(4)(iii), says that a landlord can make deductions for damage, but not for reasonable wear and tear. On a case-by-case basis, it can be difficult to decide. The SJC provided some **deciding factors between damage and reasonable use of a space**:

- Condition of the premises when lease began
- Cause of the damage
- Nature of the damage
- How the tenant used the premises
- Length of tenancy
- Expected deterioration based on the length of tenancy

 

And then, gave some illustrative examples, saying that living in the same premises for an extended period means it’s likely that there will be gradual deterioration of the property, and landlords should expect some reasonable damage to a space after a tenant’s use. **The longer a tenant stays, the more likely deterioration would be**.

 

The SJC reasoned that tenants are expected to walk around, cook, bathe, and use appliances and said it is not proper for a landlord to deduct for normal use of a property, giving several **examples of what can’t be deducted from your security deposit**:

- Scuffing on floors, walls
- Marking on doors
- Staining and “other signs of wear” on carpets
- Scuffing of any other usable surfaces

 

**LEASES CAN’T REQUIRE CLEANING FEES**

 

The SJC made it clear that lease terms that require a professional cleaning service requirement upon move out, are unenforceable. Any lease provision requiring a tenant to do so would be a violation of the security deposit statute. Tenants are expected to return the unit in a reasonable condition, but not to have to pay for professional cleaning services.

 

If you’re a landlord or tenant and unsure about whether a security deposit deduction is lawful, consult with an attorney before taking any action.

 

**Curious about a security deposit issue? Complete the form below to schedule a complimentary consultation with an experienced landlord-tenant lawyer at Clifford Law**

**Boston.**

Post by [Ami Clifford](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog/author/ami-clifford)   
 October 25, 2025

### Related Articles

##### [![Protect Your Rights: Essential Tips for Moving Into a Boston Area Rental](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/hs-fs/hubfs/CLB_Tips%20for%20Moving%20In.png?width=520&height=294&name=CLB_Tips%20for%20Moving%20In.png) Tenant Law • June 12, 2024 Protect Your Rights: Essential Tips for Moving Into a Boston Area Rental 4 min read](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog/protect-your-tenant-rights-during-move-in)

##### [![Top 10 Tips for Maximizing Your Security Deposit When Moving Out](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/hs-fs/hubfs/CLB_Tips%20for%20Protecting%20Security%20Deposit%20Moving%20Out%20(1).png?width=520&height=294&name=CLB_Tips%20for%20Protecting%20Security%20Deposit%20Moving%20Out%20(1).png) Tenant Law • May 07, 2024 Top 10 Tips for Maximizing Your Security Deposit When Moving Out 4 min read](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog/10-essential-security-deposit-tips-when-moving-out)

![CLB Offer Graphic 300x300_Security Deposit Contingency Program](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/hs-fs/hubfs/CLB%20Offer%20Graphic%20300x300_Security%20Deposit%20Contingency%20Program.png?width=300&height=300&name=CLB%20Offer%20Graphic%20300x300_Security%20Deposit%20Contingency%20Program.png)

### Find Out if You're Eligible!

Are you struggling to get your security deposit back? If your landlord didn't comply with the law, you might be eligible for treble damages of up to 3x the amount of your deposit. See if you're eligible for a free consult by clicking on the below link and completing the online form\*:

### **[Application Form](https://www.jotform.com/form/222416572532048)**

 

***\* IMPORTANT: filling out this form does not guarantee representation***

 

 

###### Categories

- [Security Deposit](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog/tag/security-deposit)
- [Tenant Law](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog/tag/tenant-law)
- [Landlord](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog/tag/landlord)

###### Recent Posts

![Clifford-Law-Boston-Blue](https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Clifford-Law-Boston-Blue.png?width=250&height=66&name=Clifford-Law-Boston-Blue.png)

**☎️** [617-202-6806](tel:6172026806)

 

**92 State Street, 2nd Floor**

**Boston, MA 02109**

 

 

©2026 Clifford Law Boston. All rights reserved.

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Ami Clifford",
    "url" : "https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog/author/ami-clifford"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2025-10-25T18:52:28.338Z",
  "datePublished" : "2025-10-25T18:52:28.000Z",
  "headline" : "Peebles v. JRK Property Case Summary: Recent Massachusetts Case Defining Proper Security Deposit Handling",
  "image" : [ "https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/hubfs/AI-Generated%20Media/Images/The%20image%20depicts%20a%20courtroom%20setting%20with%20a%20judge%20presiding%20over%20a%20case%20The%20judge%20an%20older%20man%20in%20a%20black%20robe%20sits%20behind%20a%20wooden%20bench%20looking%20att-1.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/blog/peebles-v.-jrk-property-case-summary-recent-massachusetts-case-defining-proper-security-deposit-handling",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://www.cliffordlawboston.com/hubfs/CLO%20Logo_screenshot.png"
    },
    "name" : "Clifford Law Boston"
  }
}
```